The Hillyard branch of Spokane Public Library, a modern red and brick building with large windows and a lawn, with the Cordelia Anderson Consulting logo at right on a white panel.
AI & Digital Literacy, From the Field, Thought Leadership

Library Funding Advocacy: A Recap of Amanda Donovan at LMCC 2026

2026 Library Marketing and Communications Conference · St. Louis, Missouri · November 11–12, 2026

I serve on the board that plans the Library Marketing and Communications Conference, and every year I come home with more ideas than I know what to do with. This one is from Amanda Donovan’s session at LMCC 2026 in St. Louis — on library funding, public trust, and how we talk about money. The framework and the stories are Amanda’s; what follows is my summary and my reflections on why it stuck with me.

The Session

Amanda Donovan, Director of Marketing & Communications at Spokane Public Library, opened Civic Lessons: Library Funding, Public Trust & Communicating Value with a question: what does your community — and your staff — actually know about how your library is funded? Her guess: not much. She was blissfully unaware herself for years, she admitted, because it’s a privilege not to have to think about money when money isn’t tight.

Her argument was that most libraries in the room are underfunded, and that the pressure is structural. She cited rising safety and security costs, exploitative e-book and audiobook pricing, climbing insurance, inflation, politically motivated cuts — and what she called systemic underfunding rooted in a century of treating librarianship as women’s work.

Women make up 89.2% of librarians and 84.2% of library assistants, she noted, and the low pay was intentional from the start: male leaders in the early 1900s hired women explicitly because they cost less.

She also referenced a blog by Rachel Bachman that says “the cruelest trick of feminized work is that it makes exploitation sound like a virtue. The job is meaningful, so workers are expected to accept less.”

The good news, she said, is that the public is on libraries’ side — 93% of Americans say cuts to local library services would hurt their community, across demographics and voting lines.

The Case Studies

She walked through two libraries that fought back, because both inspired the model for what Spokane did next.

San Diego Public Library faced $640 million in funding losses over 20 years. When the mayor proposed $6.3 million in cuts across 37 locations, the Library Foundation launched a campaign — sharing stories, contacting officials, submitting public comments, and sending more than 15,000 postcards. Community outcry brought the cuts down to $4.8 million. Amanda’s takeaway: a friends group or foundation can advocate when it feels politically unsafe for the library itself to do so.

New York Public Library, with Brooklyn and Queens, faced $58.3 million in proposed cuts that would have closed branches and cost 730 jobs. Their in-house team ran a campaign — Don’t Close the Book on Libraries — on a shoestring budget, with rallies, translated signs, email, and social media that went viral (Kermit the Frog, Sarah Jessica Parker). The budget was restored in 2024 and codified under the next mayor. Amanda’s takeaway: libraries deserve a funding ecosystem where they’re not spending half the year fighting for money instead of serving their communities.

The Spokane Story

Spokane Public Library was facing a $2.3 million shortfall and, for three years, had quietly absorbed the cuts — cutting travel, leaving positions unfilled, dipping into reserves. Then the executive director came to Amanda and said, let’s go all Brooklyn, all the time. Her response, she joked: “…but we’re not Brooklyn.” No celebrity power, no Kermit, a more conservative voter base.

They did it anyway. Phase 1, on November 13, 2025, was a simple public post and email to all patrons — a special budget message from the executive director — explaining the situation, with a call to action to contact city council. It generated real media coverage, a letter to the editor from the board of trustees, and heartwarming emails from across the community, including a principal who wrote about the library’s impact on the school community. They secured $500,000 in bridge funding for 2026. Not nearly what they needed, and the money was complicated, but it looked like a win and it saved face. The real fight, Amanda said, was for long-term sustainable money.

Phase 2 was a year-long “slow-drip” campaign called Your Library, Your Investment — monthly messages building understanding and trust so the funding conversation never had to come out of the blue. March was the big-picture “we need a budget that sustains library resources,” with peer comparisons. April was Library Funding 101 — explaining that 67% of their budget comes from the city’s general fund, 18% from a voter-approved levy, and that bond money can only pay for buildings. May made the case that a library budget doesn’t go as far as a household budget, and that staff are the biggest line item. June was the philosophical piece — libraries as essential to democracy, needing fair and unbiased funding. July got real: naming the service cuts on the table if the money didn’t come through.

What I found most useful was the discipline underneath it. Every public message was paired with internal and political communication first — staff messages before public posts, city council and mayor briefings, staff talking points, advance notice of what was coming. The calendar she showed was as much an internal communications plan as an external one.

She also shared “Real Questions & Comments About the Library Budget,” each showing a patron comment above Spokane Public Library’s response.

Two side-by-side slides titled "Real Questions & Comments About the Library Budget," each showing a patron comment above Spokane Public Library's response. Left: a suggestion to donate or start a GoFundMe, answered by explaining donations and grants make up 0.8% of the budget and can't address a $2.3 million shortfall. Right: a comment claiming the library has a spending problem, answered by noting the library is doing more with less than other Western libraries and has cut vacancies, travel, and collection spending.

The Risks, and What They Did About Them

Amanda was candid that a campaign like this carries real risk, and she named five — with a fix for each.

  • Alienating staff or allies. Her solution was relentless internal communication: regular office hours with the executive director, in-person meetings, staff talking points, and advance notice of every public message. Transparency cut both ways — staff felt better knowing, and worse worrying about their jobs — but she judged that the knowing was worth it.
  • Complicated messaging. One team member told her plainly that the language was too dense. They pivoted to video, got “new eyes” on the script, and stripped the jargon down to a plain-spoken message aimed squarely at the patron.
  • Ignoring public sentiment. They used AI tools to analyze comment volume and sentiment across channels, then addressed what people were actually saying directly.
  • Not highlighting library value. Every budget message was paired with proof of what the library delivers. The comments she showed made the point better than any chart — one patron who’d assumed the library was irrelevant discovered it had a podcast studio, and the reply that landed was: how do you think other cities get those cool things? Funding.
  • Overcommunication. The slow drip was deliberate — time messages carefully, monitor engagement, and suspend communication when needed. When the Spokane Complex Fires devastated the city in August, they halted budget communications entirely. It was the right call, and the board’s budget update waited until the community had room to hear it.

She was also honest about the challenges. The campaign ruffled political feathers — the mayor, specifically — and she was upfront that you have to be ready for that tension if you’re going to speak up for yourself.

What I Took Back

Three things I’m still thinking about:

  • Talking about money is educating, not complaining. The taboo around money conversations is exactly what keeps libraries underfunded. Getting comfortable with it is part of the job.
  • The case for funding is a story, not a spreadsheet. The most effective moments in the session were the ones that made you feel the stakes — the principal’s email, the video naming what layoffs would mean. Numbers alone don’t move people.
  • Start with where your library stands. Amanda’s practical tip: even if you never share it publicly, know how your library’s budget and staffing compare to peers. You can’t make the case for more if you don’t know where you are.

Her close was a call to action, and it’s the right note to end on. Her five steps for telling your library’s funding story: highlight value, demonstrate fiscal responsibility, tailor the message to your community, use the channels you have, and monitor, pivot, and adjust as needed. As she put it — we need more people to talk about the chronic underfunding of libraries. Tell your library’s funding story.


Amanda Donovan is Director of Marketing & Communications at Spokane Public Library.